1
All One Insurance Agency LLC
5.0(420 reviews)
New Castle, IN
Insurance AgentUpdated September 2026
Best Insurance Agents in New Castle, IN (2026)
Looking for a insurance agent in New Castle? We've compiled a list of the top 20 verified insurance agents in New Castle, IN based on ratings, reviews, and public business records.
57
Total Insurance Agents
20
Top Rated
4.6
Avg Rating
3,079
Total Reviews
Top 20 Insurance Agents in New Castle, IN
2
Amy Glaser - State Farm Insurance Agent
5.0(111 reviews)
New Castle, IN
3
Young's Title & Abstract
5.0(106 reviews)
New Castle, IN
4
Risk Strategies | Castle Rock Capacity Brokerage
5.0(59 reviews)
New Castle, IN
5
Adam Ruffner at Comparion Insurance Agency
5.0(45 reviews)
New Castle, IN
6
New Castle Affordable Insurance Agency
5.0(7 reviews)
New Castle, IN
7
New Castle Insurance Agency
5.0(7 reviews)
New Castle, IN
8
North Castle Insurance Agency
5.0(3 reviews)
New Castle, IN
9
Shelter Insurance - Josh Thurman
5.0(3 reviews)
New Castle, IN
10
In Title Company
5.0(1 reviews)
New Castle, IN
11
Morris Insurance & Real Estate
5.0(1 reviews)
New Castle, IN
12
North East Insurance Agency
5.0(1 reviews)
New Castle, IN
13
Doug Meier - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9(377 reviews)
New Castle, IN
14
Dimple Abraham Myers - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9(214 reviews)
New Castle, IN
15
McGowan Insurance Group
4.9(27 reviews)
New Castle, IN
16
Kentucky Farm Bureau Insurance
4.9(21 reviews)
New Castle, IN
17
Five Star Insurance Agency, LLC
4.9(16 reviews)
New Castle, IN
18
Keystone Insurance Brokers
4.8(49 reviews)
New Castle, IN
19
Koontz Insurance & Financial Services
4.8(25 reviews)
New Castle, IN
20
The Gemini Insurance Agency
4.8(24 reviews)
New Castle, IN
How We Chose These Insurance Agents
Our directory aggregates data from multiple public sources to compile the most comprehensive list of insurance agents in New Castle, IN. Here's how we evaluate and rank professionals:
- Public Licensing Records — We verify that each professional holds valid, up-to-date licenses and registrations in IN.
- NPI Registry & Business Records — For healthcare professionals, we cross-reference the National Provider Identifier registry. For other verticals, we use state business filings and industry databases.
- Customer Ratings & Reviews — We aggregate ratings from major review platforms to surface the highest-quality professionals.
- Completeness of Information — Professionals with verified contact details, addresses, and active online presence rank higher.
Tips for Choosing a Insurance Agent in New Castle
Check Reviews & Ratings
Look for insurance agents with consistently high ratings and a meaningful number of reviews. A insurance agent with 4.5 stars and 100+ reviews is generally more reliable than one with 5 stars and only 2 reviews.
Verify Credentials
Always verify that the insurance agent holds appropriate licenses for IN. Check with your state's licensing board for the most up-to-date information.
Compare Multiple Options
Don't settle for the first option. Contact at least 2-3 insurance agents to compare services, availability, and pricing before making your decision.
Ask About Experience
Inquire about the insurance agent's experience with your specific needs. Specialists who focus on particular areas may provide better outcomes than generalists.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many insurance agents are in New Castle, IN?
Our directory currently lists 57 verified insurance agents in New Castle, IN. This number is regularly updated as new professionals are added to our database.
What is the average rating for insurance agents in New Castle?
The average rating for insurance agents in New Castle, IN is 4.6 out of 5 stars, based on 3,079 total reviews across all listed professionals.
How do I choose the best insurance agent in New Castle?
Start by reviewing ratings and the number of reviews above. Look for professionals with consistent high marks and verified credentials. We recommend contacting 2-3 options to compare availability, services, and pricing.
Find a Insurance Agent in New Castle Today
Browse our complete directory of 57 insurance agents in New Castle, IN. Filter by rating, read reviews, and request quotes.
Browse All Insurance Agents in New Castle